Beyond the Benchmark is our ongoing series where we take a real ad, run it through AttentionAI and compare it with the benchmark for its format. Amplified independently selected and tested this ad. We did not create it or work with the brand or its agency.

The ad

For Episode 02 we tested Myer's 2026 Christmas ad, Say More, as a 30-second YouTube skippable pre-roll. Skippable placements are one of the toughest tests for creative: after a few seconds, every viewer gets the option to leave.

The result

‍

‍

Say More scored 7.4% above the YouTube skippable benchmark. The Creative Score compares an ad's total attention with the benchmark for its format, so this is a lead over what a typical skippable ad achieves.

Hook and hold

‍

‍

The hook measures active attention in the first 20% of the ad. Myer was 6% ahead of the benchmark here, roughly level with the norm while viewers decide whether to skip.

The hold covers the final 80%, and this is where the story changes. Myer was 117% ahead, holding more than twice the attention of a typical skippable ad once the skip button was on screen.

Why it worked

‍

‍

The chart shows how far above or below the benchmark the ad held attention, second by second. It starts level, then the gap opens from around eight seconds and keeps growing to the end. Three moments help explain why.

  1. Title over the opening (0:01). Hands at a piano with the campaign title on screen keep it level with the norm before the skip button.
  2. One small moment after another (0:13). Close-ups around the table and gifts keep arriving, and far more viewers stay past the skip than usual.
  3. A grin worth staying for (0:26). A boy beaming over his present lands late, and the ad keeps far more of its audience to the end.

Where the 30 seconds went

‍

‍

For the average viewer, 7.32 of the 30 seconds were active attention (eyes on the ad), 5.16 seconds were passive (eyes on screen, but not on the ad) and 17.52 seconds were non-attention, which on a skippable placement includes viewers who skipped. That's active attention for 24.4% of the ad's length.

At the three-second mark, 43.1% of the audience was actively watching.

Takeaways

  • On skippable formats, the hold is the real test. Matching the norm early and then out-holding it is where Myer won.
  • Brand early, before the skip. The campaign title sits over the opening shot, so even viewers who skip have seen it.
  • Keep giving people a reason to stay. A steady run of small, warm moments kept far more viewers watching than usual.
  • Judge creative against its format. A 30-second ad on skippable pre-roll faces a different norm to the same ad on TV.

Hats off to the team behind Say More - a warm, beautifully shot take on Christmas giving.

Test your ad

Want to see how your own creative compares with the benchmark for its format? Test your ad with AttentionAI.

Independently selected and tested by Amplified. Amplified did not create this ad or work with the brand or its agency.